This large, yellow brick house was built as the second home of jurist Henry Baldwin, whose move to Pittsburgh from Philadelphia launched his career as a U.S. congressman (1816–1822). In 1830, President Andrew Jackson appointed Baldwin a justice of the Supreme Court, where he served until 1844. Said to be a copy of Jackson's home, “Hunter's Hill,” near Nashville, Baldwin's house has an open gallery on all four elevations and a hipped roof. The house was incomplete when Baldwin died penniless in 1844. In 1847, William Reynolds, a nephew of Baldwin's wife, bought the property. He renovated the house in 1866, changed the roof from hipped to mansard, added a walnut stairway, a library and a conservatory in enclosed portions of the gallery, and a first-story entrance on the west elevation. The house stayed in the Reynolds family until 1963, when the Crawford County Historical Society purchased it; the society operates it as a house museum.