This is the fourth building for a congregation organized in 1793. With a tower soaring 102 feet above the surrounding buildings, the church stands out as Jersey Shore's tallest and most dramatic building. The texture of the random rock-faced sandstone and the outline of the large south cross gable and the hipped-roof rear church hall all contribute to the church's picturesque qualities. The pyramidal-roofed tower is the most dominant element, and more so before the conical-roofed turret that rose above the tower was destroyed by lightning in 1983. The church has an amphitheater plan; the two large stained glass windows were created by Capital City Art Glass and Decoration Company of Columbus, Ohio. Wagner and Reitmeyer formed a partnership in 1893; it dissolved in 1898, a year before Wagner's death. Reitmeyer practiced on his own until about 1911, after which he served in Williamsport city government for the next twenty years.